PHILOSOPHER IN THE CITY: AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF THE PLACE Article 1. Mikhail Bakhtin
DOI: 10.23951/2312-7899-2019-3-43-61
A series of articles in which the author poses the problem of the connection between the life and the biography of the philosopher with the life and biography of the city begins with this work. Through the identification of event links between the biography of a particular philosopher’s person and the places in the cities in which his life took place, the author proposes to examine the problem of how the place’s autobiography is formed. The author considers the specifics of philosophical autobiographies through the prism of the biography of the city. The article proposes a working model for the reconstruction of the author’s habitat. The reconstruction scheme is in an attempt to restore the author’s habitat and events of his life by highlighting layers consisting of socalled “units” and “organizations”. Units of reconstruction are artifacts (things, objects, material objects, results of activity), signs (texts, symbolic structures), values and meanings, events and actions. Artifacts form such organization as urban infrastructures. Signs form a city text. Values and meanings form the memory of the city. Events and actions constitute everyday life in the city. Each author, as a result, creates his own trajectory of life, his autobiography, consisting of these units, which are then restored and reconstructed by researchers. Each specific biography of a particular philosopher will be considered in the language of the proposed construct. This article discusses the biography of M. M. Bakhtin. It is shown that the sources of Bakhtin’s biography (artifacts, texts, etc.) are very scarce. The texts are fragmentary and incomplete. Events and actions are hidden and difficult to recover. Values and meanings, of course, have to be reconstructed. As a result, Bakhtin, as an author, confirms with his biography his own thesis about the outsidedness and unfinalizability of the author’s thoughts and actions. The philosopher himself tried in every possible way to disappear from the geographical map of the territory of residence, forcing researchers to engage more in the interpretation and reconstruction of the author’s life than in analyzing the real facts of his life. At the same time, even the disappearing event point, which Bakhtin as an author is for subsequent researchers, clearly shows his discrepancy with himself and also the auto-reflective, event-related nature of the philosophers’ autobiography in principle.
Keywords: autobiography, philosophical autobiography, memory visualization, city, place, artifact, event, city text
References:
Avanesov 2017 – Avanesov S. S. To the problem of “human” ontology: actuality of Bakhtin’s thought. Chelovek.RU. Almanac of the Humanities. 2017. 12. P. 127–158. In Russian.
Bakhtin 2003 – Bakhtin M. М. Collected Works. Vol. 1. Philosophical aesthetics of the 1920s. Moscow, 2003. In Russian.
Bocharov 2010 – Bocharov S. G. On one conversation and around it. Mikhail Mikhailovich Bakhtin. Ed. by V. L. Makhlin. Moscow, 2010. P. 47–79. In Russian.
Duvakin 1996 – Conversations of V. D. Duvakin with M. M. Bakhtin. Moscow, 1996. In Russian.
Gachev 1993 – Gachev G. D. “So, in fact, a whole story began…”. Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. 1993. 1 (2). P. 105–108. In Russian.
Ivanov 1995 – Ivanov Vyach. Vs. On the authorship of the books of V. N. Medvedev and P. N. Voloshinov. Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. 1995. 4. P. 133–137. In Russian.
Kagan 1992 – Kagan Yu. M. On the old papers of their family archives. Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. 1992. 1. P. 61–88. In Russian.
Kagan 1995 – Kagan Yu. M. People of not our time. Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences. 1995. 1. P. 36–46. In Russian.
Kagan 2004 – Kagan M. I. About the course of history. Moscow, 2004. In Russian.
Kozhinov 1992 – How are the works or the origin of an uncreated adventure novel written? Vadim Kozhinov talks about the fate and personality of M. M. Bakhtin. Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. 1992. 1. P. 109–122. In Russian.
Konkin, Konkina 1993 – Konkin S. S., Konkina L. S. Mikhail Bakhtin: (Pages of Life and Creativity). Saransk, 1993. In Russian.
Korovashko 2017 – Korovashko A. V. Mikhail Bakhtin. Moscow, 2017. In Russian.
Kurennoy 2017 – Kurennoy V. Strength of weak ties. The city dweller and the right to loneliness. Citizen. What do we know about a resident of a big city? Moscow, 2017. P. 14–29. In Russian.
Laptun 1993 – Laptun V. I. To “Biographies of M. M. Bakhtin”. Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. 1993. 1 (2). P. 67–73. In Russian.
Losev, Losev 2005 – Losev A. F., Loseva V. M. “Joy forever”. Correspondence camp times. Moscow, 2005. In Russian.
Lotman 1996 – Lotman Yu. M. Inside the thinking worlds. Man – text – semiosphere – history. Moscow, 1996. In Russian.
Maksimovskaya 1995 – Maksimovskaya L. M. To the oral stories of M. M. Bakhtin about Nevel (comment by a local historian). Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences. 1995. 1. P. 93–105. In Russian.
Medvedev 1995 – Medvedev Yu. P. Letter to the editor of the journal “Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. 1995. 4. P. 148–156. In Russian.
Medvedev 2000 – Medvedev Yu. Bakhtin for the poor. Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. 2000. 1. P. 110–126. In Russian.
Medvedev 2008 – Medvedev Yu. P., Medvedev D. A. Works and Days of the Circle of M. M. Bakhtin. Zvezda [Star]. 2008. 7. URL: https://zvezdaspb.ru/index.php?page=8&nput=1015 In Russian.
Moreva 1993 – Metaphysics of St. Petersburg. Petersburg readings on the theory, history and philosophy of culture. Issue. I. Ed. by L. Moreva. Saint Petersburg, 1993. In Russian.
Morson, Emerson 1990 – Morson G. S., Emerson C. Mikhail Bakhtin. Creation of a Prosaics. Stanford University Press, Stanford, California. 1990.
Pankov 1993 – Pankov N. A. The Mysteries of the Early Period (A few more strokes to the biography of M. M. Bakhtin). Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. 1993. 1 (2). P. 74-89. In Russian.
Pankov 2010 – Pankov N. A. Questions of the biography and scientific creativity of M. M. Bakhtin. Moscow, 2010. In Russian.
Peshkov 2000 – Peshkov I. End – “Cause” crown. Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope. 2000. 1. P. 72–109. In Russian.
Shelski 2013 – Shelski G. Solitude and freedom. To the social idea of the German university. Transl. into Russian. Logos. 2013. 1 (91). P. 65–86.
Simmel 2002 – Simmel G. Big Cities and Spiritual Life. Transl. into Russian. Logos. 2002. 3–4.
Smirnov 2016 – Smirnov S. A. Anthropological Navigator. To the event ontology of man. Novosibirsk, 2016. In Russian.
Smirnov 2017 – Smirnov S. А. Philosopher and Revolution. To the event biographies. Personality. Culture. Society. 2017. Volume XIX. Issue 3–4 (95–96). P. 121–130. In Russian.
Smirnov, Reznik 2018 – Philosophy as an Institute. Domestic philosophy: people, systems of ideas, institutions and communities. Expert discussion. Ed. by S. A. Smirnov, Yu. M. Reznik. Chelovek.RU. Almanac of the Humanities. 2018. 13. P. 179–212. In Russian.
Thomä et al. 2017 – Thomä D., Schmid U., Kaufmann V. Der Einfall des Lebens. Theorie als geheime Autobiographie. Transl. into Russian. Moscow, 2017.
Turbin 1995 – Turbin V. N. From unpublished about M. M. Bakhtin (1). Russian Journal of Philosophical Sciences. 1995. 1. P. 235–246. In Russian.
Uvarova-Daniel 2012 – Uvarova-Daniel I. Little that kept the memory. About Bakhtin. Zvezda [Star]. 2012. 7. URL: https://zvezdaspb.ru/index.php?page=8&nput=1858 In Russian.
( 1.17 MB ) 
( 1.15 MB )
Issue: 3, 2019
Series of issue: Issue 3
Rubric: ARTICLES
Pages: 43 — 61
Downloads: 864