SACRED TOPICS OF RUSSIAN CITIES
In this article, I analyze a traditional Russian city as a visual semiotic space. I demonstrate that the key ideological (sacred) archetypes are in the basis of the planning of urban inhabited space; these archetypes have their expression in a visual forms for structuring of life environment. I understand here a topics as a method and result of an artificial spatial organization of “place”. It is important that an urban environment has a communicative character: the topical organization of inhabited space reflects and produces human communication practices. I explore a city as a multi-layered and multi-valued semiotic space in which discrete objects and their complexes “are read” as ideological, mnemonic and suggestive signs or messages (texts). Traditional Christian city is also a sacred image or spatial icon; consequently his understanding involves the use of the semiotic procedures that are used for the interpretation of iconography. For this reason I make an ontological and semiotic analysis of Eastern Christian icons, and at the same time I assert an active iconic stance of person. My study of the city as an icon based on the concept of hierotopy (Alexey Lidov) and aionotopy (Valery Lepahin). The sacred topics of Russian city historically formed by implementing the four basic organizational models (or matrices): the cultural-historical, liturgical, eschatological and symbolic; a particular paradigmatic image is the deep content of each of these models. Cultural-historical matrix assumes the transfer (distribution) of sacred space. The concept of cultural and semiotic transfer as the mechanism of constructing semantic space complexes in the formation of culture as communication environment is explained in this article. I offer the version of the systematic describing of fundamental models of translocation systems and complexes of culturally significant meanings in the formation of living space in traditional city. I suppose three types of cultural and semiotic transfer: transfer of idea, transfer of image and copying. As an example of eidetic transfer (transfer of idea), I view the process of translation of Christian sacral topos from Jerusalem through Constantinople to Kiev.
Keywords: visual semiotics, space of culture, sacred space, city, architecture, Eastern Christianity, icon, spatial icon, models of sacred topics, Russia, cultural semiotic transfer
References:
Arnheim 1984 – Arnheim R. The Dynamics of Architectural Form. Transl. into Russian. Moscow, 1984.
Aseev 1984 – Aseev Yu. S. Architecture of ancient Kiev 10th–13th centuries in the context of the world architectural process. Old Russian Town. Kiev, 1984. P. 5–10. In Russian.
Aseev and oth. 1988 – Aseev Yu. S., Totskaya I. F., Stender G. M. New about the compositional plan of St. Sophia Cathedral in Kiev. Old Russian art. The artistic culture of the 10th – first half of the 13th cent. Moscow, 1988. P. 13–27. In Russian.
Avanesov 2013 a – Avanesov S. S. Visual anthropology: image, subject and communication. Tomsk State Pedagogical University Bulletin. 2013. 9 (137). P. 229–235. In Russian.
Avanesov 2013 b – Avanesov S. S. Sacred architecture as a means of visual communication. Tomsk State University Journal of Cultural Studies and Art History. 2013. 4 (12). P. 153–157. In Russian.
Avanesov 2014 – Avanesov S. S. What can be called visual semiotics? ΠΡΑΞΗΜΑ. Journal of Visual Semiotics. 2014. 1. P. 10–22. In Russian.
Averintsev 2001 – Averintsev S. S. “Wisdom built a house for itself”: Speech at the opening of the exhibition of Russian icons in the Vatican. July 29, 1999. New World. 2001. 1. P. 162–168. In Russian.
Bachelard 2014 – Bachelard G. La poétique de l’espace. Transl. into Russian. Moscow, 2014.
Batalov, Belyaev 1998 – Batalov A. L., Belyaev L. A. Some problems of topography of the medieval Russian city. Sacred topography of a medieval city. Vol. 1. Moscow, 1998. P. 13–22. In Russian.
Baudrillard 2006 – Baudrillard J. La société de consommation: ses mythes et ses structures. Transl. into Russian. Moscow, 2006.
Bondarenko 1996 – Bondarenko A. I. Aesthetics of the Old Russian city. The artistic and aesthetic culture of Ancient Rus. 11th –17th cent. Moscow, 1996. P. 95–118. In Russian.
Bychkov 1989 – Bychkov V. V. The Tradition of symbolism in ancient Russian aesthetics. Byzantium and Rus. Moscow, 1989. P. 133–138. In Russian.
Chiornaya 2008 – Chiornaya L. A. Anthropological code of Old Russian culture. Moscow, 2008. URL: http://bookz.ru/authors/ludmila-4ernaa/antropol_711/page-40-antropol_711.html. In Russian.
Dionysius 2002 – Dionysius the Areopagite.Works. Maxim the Confessor. Explanations. Transl. into Russian. St. Petersburg, 2002.
Fedorov and oth. 2015 – Fedorov V. V., Fedorov M. V., Korotaeva Z. V.The semantic potential of architecture and landscape environment. ΠΡΑΞΗΜΑ. Journal of Visual Semiotics. 2015. 4 (6). P. 47–64. In Russian.
Genisaretsky 2015 – Genisaretsky O. I. Jerusalem’s anatopy. ΠΡΑΞΗΜΑ. Journal of Visual Semiotics. 2015. 2 (4). P. 126–131. In Russian.
Gnutova, Schedrina 2006 – Gnutova S. V., Schedrina K. A. The Holy Cross monastery, the Kyi Cross and the transfiguration of the sacred space in the age of Patriarch Nikon. Hierotopy: Creation of Sacred Spaces in Byzantium and Medieval Russia. Ed. by A. M. Lidov. Moscow, 2006. P. 681–705. In Russian.
Gulyanitsky 1993 – Old Russian town planning of 10th–15th centuries. Ed. by N. F. Gulyanitsky. Moscow, 1993. In Russian.
Guran 2009 – Guran P. The Constantinople – New Jerusalem at the crossing of sacred space and political theology. New Jerusalems: Hierotopy and iconography of sacred spaces. Ed. by A. M. Lidov. Moscow, 2009. P. 35–57.
Ikonnikov 2006 – Ikonnikov A. V. Space and form in architecture and town planning. Moscow, 2006. In Russian.
Ilyin 1963 – Ilyin M. A. Basics of Understanding Architecture. Moscow, 1963. URL: http://www.rusarch.ru/iljin1.htm. In Russian.
Ilyin 1965 – Ilyin M. A. On the name of the Tithe Church. Soviet archeology. 1965. 2. P. 266–268. In Russian.
Ioannisyan 2010 – Ioannisyan O. M. Architectural features of the Tithe Church and St. Sophia Cathedral: a comparison experience. Founding of St. Sophia Cathedral in Kiev: problems of new dating. Materials of “Roundtable”. Kiev, 2010. URL: http://www.rusarch.ru/ioannisian3.htm. In Russian.
Ivakin, Ioannisyan 2008 – Ivakin G. Yu., Ioannisyan O. M. On the new excavations of the Tithe Church (2005–2007). Proceedings of the II (XVIII) All-Russian Archaeological Congress in Suzdal. Vol. 1. Moscow, 2008. P. 12−19. In Russian.
John of Damascus 1997 – Saint John of Damascus. Works. Christological and polemical treatises. Sermons on the Theotokos holidays. Moscow, 1997.
Kirichenko 2008 – Kirichenko E. I. The church and the city: on the symbolic and structural unity of the russian sacred space. Hierotopy: Comparative Studies of Sacred Spaces. Ed. by A. M. Lidov. Moscow, 2008. P. 285–315. In Russian.
Knabe 1975 – Knabe G. S. Understanding of culture in ancient Rome and early Tacitus. History of philosophy and cultural issues. Moscow, 1975. P. 62–130. In Russian.
Kvlividze2009 – KvlividzeN. V. “Procession”. Iconography and Liturgical Performance in the Time of Ivan the Terrible. Spatial Icons. Textuality and Performativity. Moscow, 2009. P. 144–148. In Russian.
Lebedev 1995 – Lebedev L., archpriest. Theology of the Russian land. Lebedev L., archpriest. Patriarchal Moscow. Moscow, 1995. P. 285–332. In Russian.
Leonid 1883 – Proskynetarion of holy places of the Holy Jerusalem. Report of Archimandrite Leonid. St. Petersburg, 1883.
Lepahin 2007 – Lepahin V. V. Iconology and iconicity. Icon and image, iconicity and literature. Moscow, 2007. P. 129–164. In Russian.
Lidov 2006 – Lidov A. M. Hierotopy. The creation of sacred space as a form of creativity and subject of cultural history. Hierotopy: Creation of Sacred Spaces in Byzantium and Medieval Russia. Moscow, 2006. P. 9–31. In Russian.
Lidov 2009 a – Lidov A. M. Hierotopy. Spatial Icons and Image-Paradigms in Byzantine Culture. Moscow, 2009. In Russian.
Lidov 2009 b – Lidov A. M. New Jerusalems. Transferring of the Holy Land as generative matrix of Christian culture. New Jerusalems: Hierotopy and iconography of sacred spaces. Moscow, 2009. P. 5–10. In Russian.
Lidov 2009 c – Lidov A. M. Spatial icons as a performative phenomenon. Spatial Icons. Textuality and Performativity. Moscow, 2009. P. 10–23. In Russian.
Likhachov 1956 – Likhachov D. S. Medieval symbolism in the stylistic systems of Ancient Russia and ways to overcome it (to the formulation of the question). To Academician Viktor Vladimirovich Vinogradov on his sixtieth birthday: Collected papers. Moscow, 1956. P. 165-171. In Russian.
Likhachov 1985 – Likhachov D. S. City defensive semantics of Assumption Temples in Russia. Assumption Cathedral of the Moscow Kremlin. Materials and research. Moscow, 1985. P. 17–23. In Russian.
Logvin 1988 – Logvin N. G. The original appearance of the Tithe Church in Kiev. Antiquities of the Slavs and Russia. Moscow, 1988. P. 225–229. In Russian.
Lotman 2010 – Lotman Yu. M. On the Semiosphere. St. Petersburg, 2010. In Russian.
Milchik 1973 – Milchik M. Architecture in Old Russian Painting. Decorative Art of the USSR. 1973. 2 (183). P. 24–27. In Russian.
Miletskyi, Tolochko 1989 – Miletskyi A. M., Tolochko P. P. Park-Museum “Ancient Kiev”: historical and archaeological and architectural complex. Kiev, 1989. In Russian.
Molchanov 2011 – Molchanov V. I. The Constitution of Space. Judgment and body. Voprosy filosofii [Problems of Philosophy]. 2011. 10. P. 155–166. In Russian.
Musin 2009 – Musin A. E. The Litania and the Making of Sacred Space in Medieval Novgorod. Spatial Icons. Textuality and Performativity. Moscow, 2009. P. 112–117. In Russian.
Pokrovsky 1910 – Pokrovsky N. V. Monuments of Christian architecture, especially Russians. St. Petersburg, 1910. In Russian.
Rozhdestvenskaya 1994 – Rozhdestvenskaya M. V. The Image of the Holy Land in Old Russian Literature. Jerusalem in Russian Culture. Moscow, 1994. P. 8–14. In Russian.
Rybas 2010 – Rybas A. E. Mimesis in medieval Russia (on the example of “The Enlightener” by Joseph Volotsky). Similarity and imitation. St. Petersburg, 2010. С. 3–53. In Russian.
Savarenskaya 1984 – Savarenskaya T. F. History of the town planning art. Moscow, 1984. In Russian.
Sedov 2009 – Sedov Vl. V. New Jerusalem in churches over the gates in Byzantium and Old Russia. New Jerusalems: Hierotopy and iconography of sacred spaces. Moscow, 2009. С. 544–584. In Russian.
Stepanyan, Simyan 2012 – Stepanyan A. A., Simyan T. S. Yerevan as a semiotic text (the experience of reconstruction of the “beginning” and “end” of Mashtots Avenue). Critique and Semiotics. 2012. 16. P. 6–16. In Russian.
Todich 1994 – Todich B. N. The theme of the Sion Church in the temple scenery of the 13th–14th cent. Jerusalem in Russian culture. Moscow, 1994. С. 34–45. In Russian.
Toporov 1981 – Toporov V. N. Text of the city-virgin and the city-harlot in the mythological aspect. Structure of text – 81: Abstracts of the symposium. Moscow, 1981. P. 53–58. In Russian.
Trifonova 2006 – Trifonova I. O. The city as a sacred space. Medieval Russia. 2006. URL: http://rusarch.ru/trifonova1.htm. In Russian.
Uspensky 1995 – Uspensky B. A. Semiotics of Art. Moscow, 1995. In Russian.
Vaneyan 2010 – Vaneyan S. S. Architecture and iconography. “The body of a symbol” in the mirror of classical methodology. Moscow, 2010. In Russian.
Voskoboynikov 2014 – Voskoboynikov O. S. Millennial Kingdom (300–1300): Essay on the Christian culture of the West. Moscow, 2014. In Russian.
Vyatchanina 1984 – Vyatchanina T. N. On the importance of a pattern in Old Russian architecture. Architectural Heritage. Vol. 32. Moscow, 1984. P. 26–31. In Russian.
Yankovskaya 2004 – Yankovskaya Yu. S. Architectural composition and semiotics – the genesis of ideas. Architecton. Proceedings of Higher Education. 2004. 7. URL: http://archvuz.ru/2004_2/3. In Russian.
Zlatostrui 1990 – Zlatostrui [The Golden Stream]: Ancient Russia of the 10th–13th centuries. Moscow, 1990. In Russian.
( 481.06 kB ) 
( 460.33 kB )
Issue: 1, 2016
Series of issue: Issue 1
Rubric: ARTICLES
Pages: 71 — 114
Downloads: 1563